Arkian Forums

Theme

Customize your theme More languages later.
Log in / Register
Arkian Forums›Health›Weight loss

Weight loss

Discussion in Health

mmHg edited
[@fschmidt](/profile.html?user=4) Maybe [this video](https://youtu.be/v1bxl4_jeEI) can help us. Electrolyte water throughout the day, and a savory meal at night high in protein/fiber. Also, heat work (e.g., sauna). What do you think?
fschmidt Admin
He doesn't give much evidence for his beliefs. Why a lot of water? Why heat work? When fasting, I do drink electrolytes, but I do this when I feel like it, letting my body decide how much to drink. He says fat people should eat as little as possible. As little as possible is nothing, meaning fasting. You can look into extended fasting, I think it has significant benefits. I also find it easier than highly restricted eating. Once I eat something, my body tells me what else it wants to eat. When I fast, my body learns to leave me alone.
Reactions
mmHg edited
Electrolyte water for satiety (and heat work wouldn’t be safe without electrolytes), and heat work to be able to drink more electrolyte water as well as burn calories at a faster rate without exercising. It’s hard for fat people to exercise because of their joints. I like swimming, because it is easy on my joints. Chlorinated water is yucky though. As per evidence, he vlogged his weight loss journey on his YouTube but also he helps a lot of people on Facebook and Instagram and runs a Facebook group where a lot of people showcase their weight loss results. And a lot of those results are great.
mmHg
There are benefits to using the sauna as well. It is good for your joints.
fschmidt Admin
I consider my natural desires to be right unless proven wrong. Clearly they are proven wrong when I eat too much or crave sweets. But I have no reason to doubt my desires about how much to drink. I suspect that he has a satiety problem because of highly restricted eating. This isn't a problem with fasting. He could address satiety by eating zero-calorie fiber like pickles. I suspect that drinking too much water is unhealthy because it washes out water-soluble vitamins.
Reactions
mmHg edited
6-8 years ago he advocated for prolonged fasting, like 3-7 day fasts. But he changed his views a lot overtime and right now he advocates for OMAD / one meal a day. I am not sure if he had a satiety problem when he was fasting 3-7 days at a time. I find that if I snack then I get hungry, but if I eat medium-big meals then I don’t get hungry. I think my hunger is largely a psychological phenomenon, since snacking makes me feel like snacking more; perhaps my brain sees snacking as its own behavior. Idk if that resonates with you or not. He does point out that drinking too much (plain) water is unhealthy due to flushing out electrolytes / water-soluble vitamins, yes. He sells his own supplement called “snake juice” which is basically just a mixture of sodium, potassium, magnesium, and trace amounts of two other electrolytes (I forgot which ones). But sodium and potassium are the two most important I guess.
fschmidt Admin
Why did he change his views? People push all kinds of diets without much reference to scientific studies. Snacking is known to be horrible. One meal a day means that I will be hungry for much of the day. Two meals a day works for me.
mmHg edited
He changed his views because his experience tells him that prolonged fasting often leads to people bouncing back where they started and he thinks that OMAD is better for avoiding a rebound. Presumably, people psychologically treat prolonged fasting as a temporary intervention but OMAD as a long-term discipline. I don’t think he wants you to eat OMAD forever though. For one meal a day you would eat at night or whenever it would become a few hours before sleep.

Log in to reply.